Agenda for Council on Thursday, 24th February, 2022, 4.30pm

skip navigation and tools

Agenda and draft minutes

Venue: The Brighton Centre. View directions

Contact: Mark Wall  Head of Democratic Services

Items
No. Item

81.

Declarations of Interest

    (a)       Disclosable pecuniary interests;

    (b)       Any other interests required to be registered under the local code;

    (c)       Any other general interest as a result of which a decision on the matter might reasonably be regarded as affecting you or a partner more than a majority of other people or businesses in the ward/s affected by the decision.

     

    In each case, you need to declare

    (i)        the item on the agenda the interest relates to;

    (ii)       the nature of the interest; and

    (iii)      whether it is a disclosable pecuniary interest or some other interest.

     

    If unsure, Members should seek advice from the Monitoring Officer or Democratic Services Officer preferably before the meeting.

    Minutes:

    81.1      Councillor Brown declared a personal and prejudicial interest as she held a pension with East Sussex County Council. She confirmed that she had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.2      Councillor Peltzer Dunn declared a personal and prejudicial interest as he was in receipt of an East Sussex Pension and owned a beach hut. He confirmed that he had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.3      Councillor Theobald declared a personal and prejudicial interest as she held a pension with East Sussex County Council. She confirmed that she had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.4      Councillor Simson declared a personal and prejudicial interest as she held a pension with East Sussex County Council. She confirmed that she had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.5      Councillor Nemeth declared a personal and prejudicial interest as he was involved with the Beach Hut Association and an officer of Hove Lagoon Association. He confirmed that he had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.6      Councillor Meadows declared a personal and prejudicial interest as she held a pension with East Sussex County Council. She confirmed that she had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.7      Councillor Barnett declared a personal and prejudicial interest as she held a pension with East Sussex County Council. She confirmed that she had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.8      Councillor Atkinson declared a personal and prejudicial interest as he and his wife both worked for the Sussex Partnership NHS Trust and the council had a number of jointly funded services with the Trust.  He confirmed that he had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.9      Councillor Mears declared a personal and prejudicial interest as she was in receipt of an East Sussex pension and also as the mayor-elect and the civic office was affected by an amendment should it be carried. She confirmed that she had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.10   Councillor Shanks declared a personal and prejudicial interest as she was a Trustee of Brighton Youth Centre which would benefit from capital funding. She confirmed that she had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.11   Councillor Mac Cafferty declared a personal and prejudicial interest as he was a member of the East Sussex Credit Union and on the Board of  the Brighton Dome & Festival and Royal Pavilion Museum Trust. He confirmed that he had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.12   Councillor Clare declared a personal and prejudicial interest as she held bonds in the Big Lemon Bus company. She confirmed that she had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.13   Councillor Druitt declared a personal and prejudicial interest as he was the General Manager of Brighton & Hove Community Transport and Director of the Big Lemon. He confirmed that he had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.14   Councillor Gibson declared a personal and prejudicial interest as he held an East Sussex pension and was a member of the East Sussex Credit Union. He confirmed that he had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.15   Councillor Hugh-Jones declared a personal and prejudicial interest in the items listed as she held some Bonds in the Big Lemon Bus Company. She confirmed that she had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.16   Councillor Deane declared a personal and prejudicial interest as she was the deputy mayor-elect and the civic office was affected by an amendment should it be carried. She confirmed that she had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.17   Councillor Phillips declared a personal and prejudicial interest as she was married to Councillor Druitt and therefore benefitted from the interests he had declared. She confirmed that she had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.18   Councillor West declared a personal and non-prejudicial interest as he was a member of the Brighton & Hove Estate Conservation Trust and the wood recycling organisation. He confirmed that he had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.19   Councillor Powell declared a personal and prejudicial interest declared a personal interest as she was employed by Sussex Police and had a pension with East Sussex. She confirmed that she had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer.

     

    81.20   Councillor Janio declared a personal and prejudicial interest declared a personal interest as his partner held a trader’s permit. He confirmed that he had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.21   Councillor Appich declared a personal and non-prejudicial interest as her partner was the treasurer for Friends of St Anne’s Well Park. She was also a member of the GMB and the East Sussex Credit Union. She confirmed that she had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.22   Councillor Yates declared a personal and prejudicial interest as he was employed by the University Hospital NHS Trust and his partner was employed by Sanctuary Housing Association. He confirmed that he had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.23   Councillor Allcock declared a personal interest as he held an East Sussex pension and partner had an allotment. He confirmed that he had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.24   Councillor Pissaridou declared a personal and non-prejudicial interest as she had an East Sussex pension and a member of the GMB. She confirmed that she had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.25   Councillor Childs declared a personal and prejudicial interest as he was a NEU Senior Regional Officer and confirmed that he had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.26   Councillor Fowler declared a personal and prejudicial interest as her partner was employed at City Clean. She confirmed that she had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.27   Councillor Bell declared a personal and prejudicial interest as was a Trustee of the Royal Pavilion Trust. He confirmed that he had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.28   Councillor Robins declared a personal and prejudicial interest as was a Trustee of the Royal Pavilion Trust. He confirmed that he had been granted dispensation to speak and vote on the budget by the Monitoring Officer;

     

    81.29   No other declarations of interests in matters appearing on the agenda were made.

82.

Mayor's Communications.

    To receive communications from the Mayor.

    Minutes:

    82.1      The mayor gave the following communications:

     

    I have only one communication:

    As Members may be aware, this will sadly be Mark Wall’s last Council meeting as he will be leaving the Council at the end of March. He began working with the old Brighton Borough in 1986, more than 35 years ago. He rose through the ranks to his current position as Head of Democratic Services. He has served under administrations of all political colours with integrity, impartiality and absolute dedication. He has been the face of public service at its best. Mark has been the keystone that holds the democratic decision-making machinery together in Brighton & Hove and our democracy has been much richer for his work.

     

    The active political culture and vibrant public engagement in our city means it is always challenging for whoever is the Head of Democratic Services. But Mark has done it with flair and absolute professionalism. At a personal level, he has supported me as Mayor both for Council meetings and in running the Mayor’s Office. He was instrumental in getting the Council the Member Development Charter and in December the Member Development Charter Plus award.

     

    There will be an opportunity to say goodbye to Mark at the end of March, but for now, I just want to thank him for all his years of dedicated service to the Council and wish him all the best for the future.

     

    82.2      I am hopeful that we can reach a decision today. I will be taking regular short breaks during the meeting to give everyone in the chamber an opportunity to get some fresh air and remove their masks.

     

    I also wanted to reiterate that everyone needs to be mindful of each other so that we have a respectful debate and would like to draw Members’ attention to the updated procedural note that will be followed and has been circulated to help with the flow of the meeting.

83.

General Fund Revenue Budget, Capital & Treasury Management Strategy 2022/23 pdf icon PDF 204 KB

    • View the background to item 83.

    Extract from the proceedings of the Policy & Resources Committee meeting held on the 10 February, together with a report of the Chief Financial Officer.

    Additional documents:

    Minutes:

    83.1         The mayor noted that the principal budget items listed as Items 83  and 85 would be debated together, along with Item 84 Supplementary Financial Information, once the proposed budget and various amendments had been moved and seconded.

     

    83.2         He therefore invited Councillor Gibson to propose the budget for 2022//23.

     

    83.3         Councillor Gibson thanked the mayor and formally moved the budget proposals on behalf of the Administration, together with the one Green Group amendment and the joint Green and Labour amendment.

     

    83.4         Councillor Mac Cafferty spoke on the budget position and formally seconded the proposals together with the Green Group amendment and the joint Green and Labour amendment.

     

    83.5         Councillor Appich spoke on the budget and formally moved the Labour Group’s amendments No’s 1 – 4, together with the joint Green and Labour amendment .

     

    83.6         Councillor Allcock spoke on the budget and formally seconded the Labour Group’s amendments together with the joint Green and Labour amendment.

     

    83.7         Councillor McNair spoke on the budget and formally moved the Conservative Group’s amendments No’s 1 – 6.

     

    83.8         Councillor Bell spoke on the budget and formally seconded the Conservative Group’s amendments.

     

    83.9         The mayor then opened the matter up to a general debate and the following Members of the Council spoke on the various amendments that had been put forward as well as the general prevailing budget proposals and budget position.

     

    Councillors Heley, Williams, Barnett,  Janio, Powell, Wilkinson, Brown, Knight and Hugh-Jones.

     

    83.10      The mayor noted that the meeting had been in session for just over two hours and declared that he would adjourn for a refreshment break from 6.32  to 7.03pm.

     

    83.11      The mayor reconvened the meeting at 7.03pm and continued with the debate, during which the following Members spoke on various amendments that had been put forward as well as the general prevailing budget proposals and position.

     

    Councillors O’Quinn, Lewry, Davis, Moonan, Meadows, Hills, Childs, Mears, Shanks, O’Quinn (with the mayor’s agreement on behalf of Cllr Hamilton), Nemeth, Ebel, Platts, Peltzer Dunn, Phillips, Yates, Simson, Osborne, Grimshaw, Theobald, Lloyd, Fowler, Druitt, Evans and Deane.

     

    83.12      The mayor noted that all Members wising to speak during the debate had done so and called on Councillor Clare to respond to the debate and the amendments on behalf of the Administration.

     

    83.13      Councillor Clare thanked the mayor and stated that it had been a good and useful debate overall. She felt that although a number of the amendments could not be accepted, there were a lot of good suggestions that could be taken into consideration and possibly incorporated into future decisions. She therefore hoped that the budget proposals together with the amendments that could be accepted would be approved and recommended it to Council.

     

    83.14      The mayor stated that in view of the fact that the amendments related to the General Fund, he intended to put each one to the vote.  However, he would call on the Chief Finance Officer to confirm the budgetary position should any amendment be carried and have an impact on the overall budget as necessary.  He would then put the substantive recommendations to the vote as outlined in the procedural rules and also noted that the outcome of the voting would be recorded in full.

     

    83.15      The mayor then put the Green Group amendment to the vote.

     

    Green Group Amendment

     

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

    1

    Allcock

    ?

     

     

    28

    Lewry

    ?

     

     

    2

    Appich

    ?

     

     

    29

    Littman

    Not present

    3

    Atkinson

    ?

     

     

    30

    Lloyd

    ?

     

     

    4

    Bagaeen

    Not present

    31

    Mac Cafferty

    ?

     

     

    5

    Barnett

    ?

     

     

    32

    McNair

    ?

     

     

    6

    Bell

    ?

     

     

    33

    Meadows

    ?

     

     

    7

    Brennan

    Not present

     

    Mears

    ?

     

     

    8

    Brown

    ?

     

     

    35

    Miller

    Not present

    9

    Childs

    ?

     

     

    36

    Moonan

    ?

     

     

    10

    Clare

    ?

     

     

    37

    Nemeth

    ?

     

     

    11

    Davis

    ?

     

     

    38

    Nield

    Not present

    12

    Deane

    ?

     

     

    39

    O’Quinn

    ?

     

     

    13

    Druitt

    ?

     

     

    40

    Osborne

    ?

     

     

    14

    Ebel

    ?

     

     

    41

    Peltzer Dunn

    ?

     

     

    15

    Evans

    ?

     

     

    42

    Phillips

    Not present

    16

    Fishleigh

    Not present

    43

    Pissaridou

    ?

     

     

    17

    Fowler

    ?

     

     

    44

    Platts

    ?

     

     

    18

    Gibson

    ?

     

     

    45

    Powell

    ?

     

     

    19

    Grimshaw

    ?

     

     

    46

    Rainey

    Not present

    20

    Hamilton

    Not present

    47

    Robins

    ?

     

     

    21

    Heley

    ?

     

     

    48

    Shanks

    ?

     

     

    22

    Henry

    Not present

    49

    Simson

    ?

     

     

     

    Hills

    ?

     

     

     

    Theobald C

    ?

     

     

    24

    Hugh-Jones

    ?

     

     

    51

    Wilkinson

    ?

     

     

    25

    Janio

     

    x

     

    52

    Williams

    ?

     

     

    26

    John

    Not present

    53

    West

    ?

     

     

    27

    Knight

    ?

     

     

    54

    Yates

    ?

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Total

    42

    1

    0

     

     

    83.16      The mayor confirmed that the amendment had been carried by 42 votes to 1 with 0 abstentions.

     

    83.17      The mayor then put the joint Green and Labour amendment to the vote.

     

    Joint Green and Labour Amendment

     

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

    1

    Allcock

    ?

     

     

    28

    Lewry

    x

     

    2

    Appich

    ?

     

     

    29

    Littman

    Not present

    3

    Atkinson

    ?

     

     

    30

    Lloyd

    ?

     

     

    4

    Bagaeen

    Not present

    31

    Mac Cafferty

    ?

     

     

    5

    Barnett

     

    x

     

    32

    McNair

    x

     

    6

    Bell

     

    x

     

    33

    Meadows

    x

     

    7

    Brennan

    Not present

     

    Mears

     

    x

     

    8

    Brown

    x

     

    35

    Miller

    Not present

    9

    Childs

    ?

     

     

    36

    Moonan

    ?

     

     

    10

    Clare

    ?

     

     

    37

    Nemeth

     

    x

     

    11

    Davis

    ?

     

     

    38

    Nield

    Not present

    12

    Deane

    ?

     

     

    39

    O’Quinn

    ?

     

     

    13

    Druitt

    ?

     

     

    40

    Osborne

    ?

     

     

    14

    Ebel

    ?

     

     

    41

    Peltzer Dunn

     

    x

     

    15

    Evans

    ?

     

     

    42

    Phillips

    Not present

    16

    Fishleigh

    Not present

    43

    Pissaridou

    ?

     

     

    17

    Fowler

    ?

     

     

    44

    Platts

    ?

     

     

    18

    Gibson

    ?

     

     

    45

    Powell

    ?

     

     

    19

    Grimshaw

    ?

     

     

    46

    Rainey

    Not present

    20

    Hamilton

    Not present

    47

    Robins

    ?

     

     

    21

    Heley

    ?

     

     

    48

    Shanks

    ?

     

     

    22

    Henry

    Not present

    49

    Simson

     

    x

     

     

    Hills

    ?

     

     

     

    Theobald C

     

    x

     

    24

    Hugh-Jones

    ?

     

     

    51

    Wilkinson

    ?

     

     

    25

    Janio

    ?

     

     

    52

    Williams

    ?

     

     

    26

    John

    Not present

    53

    West

    ?

     

     

    27

    Knight

    ?

     

     

    54

    Yates

    ?

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Total

    32

    11

    0

     

    83.18      The mayor confirmed that the amendment had been carried by 32 votes to 11 against with 0 abstentions.

     

    83.19      The mayor then put the Labour Group amendment No.1 to the vote.

     

    Labour Group Amendment No.1

     

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

    1

    Allcock

    ?

     

     

    28

    Lewry

    x

     

    2

    Appich

    ?

     

     

    29

    Littman

    Not present

    3

    Atkinson

     

    Ab

    30

    Lloyd

    ?

     

     

    4

    Bagaeen

    Not present

    31

    Mac Cafferty

    ?

     

     

    5

    Barnett

     

    x

     

    32

    McNair

    x

     

    6

    Bell

     

    x

     

    33

    Meadows

    x

     

    7

    Brennan

    Not present

     

    Mears

     

    x

     

    8

    Brown

    x

     

    35

    Miller

    Not present

    9

    Childs

    ?

     

     

    36

    Moonan

    ?

     

     

    10

    Clare

    ?

     

     

    37

    Nemeth

     

    x

     

    11

    Davis

    ?

     

     

    38

    Nield

    Not present

    12

    Deane

    ?

     

     

    39

    O’Quinn

    ?

     

     

    13

    Druitt

    ?

     

     

    40

    Osborne

    ?

     

     

    14

    Ebel

    ?

     

     

    41

    Peltzer Dunn

     

    x

     

    15

    Evans

    ?

     

     

    42

    Phillips

    Not present

    16

    Fishleigh

    Not present

    43

    Pissaridou

    ?

     

     

    17

    Fowler

    ?

     

     

    44

    Platts

    ?

     

     

    18

    Gibson

    ?

     

     

    45

    Powell

    ?

     

     

    19

    Grimshaw

    ?

     

     

    46

    Rainey

    Not present

    20

    Hamilton

    Not present

    47

    Robins

    ?

     

     

    21

    Heley

    ?

     

     

    48

    Shanks

    ?

     

     

    22

    Henry

    Not present

    49

    Simson

     

    x

     

     

    Hills

    ?

     

     

     

    Theobald C

     

    x

     

    24

    Hugh-Jones

    ?

     

     

    51

    Wilkinson

    ?

     

     

    25

    Janio

     

    x

     

    52

    Williams

    ?

     

     

    26

    John

    Not present

    53

    West

    ?

     

     

    27

    Knight

    ?

     

     

    54

    Yates

    ?

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Total

    30

    12

    1

     

     

    83.20      The mayor confirmed that the amendment had been carried by 30 votes to 12 against with 1 abstention.

     

    83.21      The mayor then put the Labour Group amendment No.2 to the vote.

     

    Labour Group Amendment No.2

     

     

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

    1

    Allcock

    ?

     

     

    28

    Lewry

    x

     

    2

    Appich

    ?

     

     

    29

    Littman

    Not present

    3

    Atkinson

    ?

     

     

    30

    Lloyd

    ?

     

     

    4

    Bagaeen

    Not present

    31

    Mac Cafferty

    ?

     

     

    5

    Barnett

     

    x

     

    32

    McNair

    x

     

    6

    Bell

     

    x

     

    33

    Meadows

    x

     

    7

    Brennan

    Not present

     

    Mears

     

    x

     

    8

    Brown

    x

     

    35

    Miller

    Not present

    9

    Childs

    ?

     

     

    36

    Moonan

    ?

     

     

    10

    Clare

    ?

     

     

    37

    Nemeth

     

    x

     

    11

    Davis

    ?

     

     

    38

    Nield

    Not present

    12

    Deane

    ?

     

     

    39

    O’Quinn

    ?

     

     

    13

    Druitt

    ?

     

     

    40

    Osborne

    ?

     

     

    14

    Ebel

    ?

     

     

    41

    Peltzer Dunn

     

    x

     

    15

    Evans

    ?

     

     

    42

    Phillips

    Not present

    16

    Fishleigh

    Not present

    43

    Pissaridou

    ?

     

     

    17

    Fowler

    ?

     

     

    44

    Platts

    ?

     

     

    18

    Gibson

    ?

     

     

    45

    Powell

    ?

     

     

    19

    Grimshaw

    ?

     

     

    46

    Rainey

    Not present

    20

    Hamilton

    Not present

    47

    Robins

    ?

     

     

    21

    Heley

    ?

     

     

    48

    Shanks

    ?

     

     

    22

    Henry

    Not present

    49

    Simson

     

    x

     

     

    Hills

    ?

     

     

     

    Theobald C

     

    x

     

    24

    Hugh-Jones

    ?

     

     

    51

    Wilkinson

    ?

     

     

    25

    Janio

     

    x

     

    52

    Williams

    ?

     

     

    26

    John

    Not present

    53

    West

    ?

     

     

    27

    Knight

    ?

     

     

    54

    Yates

    ?

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Total

    31

    12

    0

     

     

    83.22      The mayor confirmed that the amendment had been carried by 31 votes to 12 against with 0 abstentions.

     

    83.23      The mayor then put the Labour Group amendment No.3 to the vote.

     

    Labour Group Amendment No.3

     

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

    1

    Allcock

    ?

     

     

    28

    Lewry

    x

     

    2

    Appich

    ?

     

     

    29

    Littman

    Not present

    3

    Atkinson

    ?

     

     

    30

    Lloyd

    ?

     

     

    4

    Bagaeen

    Not present

    31

    Mac Cafferty

    ?

     

     

    5

    Barnett

     

    x

     

    32

    McNair

    x

     

    6

    Bell

     

    x

     

    33

    Meadows

    x

     

    7

    Brennan

    Not present

     

    Mears

     

    x

     

    8

    Brown

    x

     

    35

    Miller

    Not present

    9

    Childs

    ?

     

     

    36

    Moonan

    ?

     

     

    10

    Clare

    ?

     

     

    37

    Nemeth

     

    x

     

    11

    Davis

    ?

     

     

    38

    Nield

    Not present

    12

    Deane

    ?

     

     

    39

    O’Quinn

    ?

     

     

    13

    Druitt

    ?

     

     

    40

    Osborne

    ?

     

     

    14

    Ebel

    ?

     

     

    41

    Peltzer Dunn

     

    x

     

    15

    Evans

    ?

     

     

    42

    Phillips

    Not present

    16

    Fishleigh

    Not present

    43

    Pissaridou

    ?

     

     

    17

    Fowler

    ?

     

     

    44

    Platts

    ?

     

     

    18

    Gibson

    ?

     

     

    45

    Powell

    ?

     

     

    19

    Grimshaw

    ?

     

     

    46

    Rainey

    Not present

    20

    Hamilton

    Not present

    47

    Robins

    ?

     

     

    21

    Heley

    ?

     

     

    48

    Shanks

    ?

     

     

    22

    Henry

    Not present

    49

    Simson

     

    x

     

     

    Hills

    ?

     

     

     

    Theobald C

     

    x

     

    24

    Hugh-Jones

    ?

     

     

    51

    Wilkinson

    ?

     

     

    25

    Janio

     

    x

     

    52

    Williams

    ?

     

     

    26

    John

    Not present

    53

    West

    ?

     

     

    27

    Knight

    ?

     

     

    54

    Yates

    ?

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Total

    31

    12

    0

     

    83.24      The mayor confirmed that the amendment had been carried by 31 votes to 12 against with 0 abstentions.

     

     

    83.25      The mayor then put the Labour Group amendment No.4 to the vote.

     

    Labour Group Amendment No.4

     

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

    1

    Allcock

    ?

     

     

    28

    Lewry

    x

     

    2

    Appich

    ?

     

     

    29

    Littman

    Not present

    3

    Atkinson

    ?

     

     

    30

    Lloyd

    ?

     

     

    4

    Bagaeen

    Not present

    31

    Mac Cafferty

    ?

     

     

    5

    Barnett

     

    x

     

    32

    McNair

    x

     

    6

    Bell

     

    x

     

    33

    Meadows

    x

     

    7

    Brennan

    Not present

     

    Mears

     

    x

     

    8

    Brown

    x

     

    35

    Miller

    Not present

    9

    Childs

    ?

     

     

    36

    Moonan

    ?

     

     

    10

    Clare

    ?

     

     

    37

    Nemeth

     

    x

     

    11

    Davis

    ?

     

     

    38

    Nield

    Not present

    12

    Deane

    ?

     

     

    39

    O’Quinn

    ?

     

     

    13

    Druitt

    ?

     

     

    40

    Osborne

    ?

     

     

    14

    Ebel

    ?

     

     

    41

    Peltzer Dunn

     

    x

     

    15

    Evans

    ?

     

     

    42

    Phillips

    Not present

    16

    Fishleigh

    Not present

    43

    Pissaridou

    ?

     

     

    17

    Fowler

    ?

     

     

    44

    Platts

    ?

     

     

    18

    Gibson

    ?

     

     

    45

    Powell

    ?

     

     

    19

    Grimshaw

    ?

     

     

    46

    Rainey

    Not present

    20

    Hamilton

    Not present

    47

    Robins

    ?

     

     

    21

    Heley

    ?

     

     

    48

    Shanks

    ?

     

     

    22

    Henry

    Not present

    49

    Simson

     

    x

     

     

    Hills

    ?

     

     

     

    Theobald C

     

    x

     

    24

    Hugh-Jones

    ?

     

     

    51

    Wilkinson

    ?

     

     

    25

    Janio

     

    x

     

    52

    Williams

    ?

     

     

    26

    John

    Not present

    53

    West

    ?

     

     

    27

    Knight

    ?

     

     

    54

    Yates

    ?

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Total

    31

    12

    0

     

    83.26      The mayor confirmed that the amendment had been carried by 31 votes to 12 against with 0 abstentions.

     

    83.27      The mayor then put the Conservative Group amendment No.1 to the vote.

     

    Conservative Group Amendment No.1

     

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

    1

    Allcock

     

    x

     

    28

    Lewry

    ?

     

    2

    Appich

     

    x

     

    29

    Littman

    Not present

    3

    Atkinson

     

    x

     

    30

    Lloyd

     

    x

     

    4

    Bagaeen

    Not present

    31

    Mac Cafferty

     

    x

     

    5

    Barnett

    ?

     

    32

    McNair

    ?

     

     

    6

    Bell

    ?

     

    33

    Meadows

    ?

     

     

    7

    Brennan

    Not present

     

    Mears

    ?

     

     

    8

    Brown

    ?

     

    35

    Miller

    Not present

    9

    Childs

     

    x

     

    36

    Moonan

    x

     

    10

    Clare

     

    x

     

    37

    Nemeth

    ?

     

    11

    Davis

     

    x

     

    38

    Nield

    Not present

    12

    Deane

     

    x

     

    39

    O’Quinn

    x

     

    13

    Druitt

     

    x

     

    40

    Osborne

    x

     

    14

    Ebel

     

    x

     

    41

    Peltzer Dunn

    ?

     

    15

    Evans

     

    x

     

    42

    Phillips

    Not present

    16

    Fishleigh

    Not present

    43

    Pissaridou

     

    x

     

    17

    Fowler

     

    x

     

    44

    Platts

     

    x

     

    18

    Gibson

     

    x

     

    45

    Powell

     

    x

     

    19

    Grimshaw

     

    x

     

    46

    Rainey

    Not present

    20

    Hamilton

    Not present

    47

    Robins

    x

     

    21

    Heley

    x

     

    48

    Shanks

    x

     

    22

    Henry

    Not present

    49

    Simson

    ?

     

     

     

    Hills

    x

     

    ?

    Theobald C

    ?

     

     

    24

    Hugh-Jones

    x

     

    51

    Wilkinson

     

    x

     

    25

    Janio

    ?

     

    52

    Williams

     

    x

     

    26

    John

    Not present

    53

    West

     

    x

     

    27

    Knight

    x

     

    54

    Yates

    x

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Total

    12

    31

    0

     

    83.28      The mayor confirmed that the amendment had been lost by 12 votes to 31 against with 0 abstentions.

     

    83.29      The mayor then put the Conservative Group amendment No.2 to the vote.

     

    Conservative Group Amendment No.2

     

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

    1

    Allcock

     

    x

     

    28

    Lewry

    ?

     

    2

    Appich

     

    x

     

    29

    Littman

    Not present

    3

    Atkinson

    ?

     

     

    30

    Lloyd

     

    x

     

    4

    Bagaeen

    Not present

    31

    Mac Cafferty

     

    x

     

    5

    Barnett

    ?

    x

     

    32

    McNair

    ?

     

     

    6

    Bell

    ?

    x

     

    33

    Meadows

    ?

     

     

    7

    Brennan

    Not present

     

    Mears

    ?

     

     

    8

    Brown

    ?

     

    35

    Miller

    Not present

    9

    Childs

     

    x

     

    36

    Moonan

    x

     

    10

    Clare

     

    x

     

    37

    Nemeth

    ?

     

    11

    Davis

     

    x

     

    38

    Nield

    Not present

    12

    Deane

     

    x

     

    39

    O’Quinn

    x

     

    13

    Druitt

     

    x

     

    40

    Osborne

    x

     

    14

    Ebel

     

    x

     

    41

    Peltzer Dunn

    ?

     

    15

    Evans

     

    x

     

    42

    Phillips

    Not present

    16

    Fishleigh

    Not present

    43

    Pissaridou

     

    x

     

    17

    Fowler

     

    x

     

    44

    Platts

     

    x

     

    18

    Gibson

     

    x

     

    45

    Powell

     

    x

     

    19

    Grimshaw

     

    x

     

    46

    Rainey

    Not present

    20

    Hamilton

    Not present

    47

    Robins

    x

     

    21

    Heley

    x

     

    48

    Shanks

    x

     

    22

    Henry

    Not present

    49

    Simson

    ?

     

     

     

    Hills

    x

     

    ?

    Theobald C

    ?

     

     

    24

    Hugh-Jones

    x

     

    51

    Wilkinson

     

    x

     

    25

    Janio

    ?

     

    52

    Williams

     

    x

     

    26

    John

    Not present

    53

    West

     

    x

     

    27

    Knight

    x

     

    54

    Yates

    x

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Total

    13

    30

    0

     

    83.30      The mayor confirmed that the amendment had been lost by 13 votes to 30 against with 0 abstentions.

     

    83.31      The mayor then put the Conservative Group amendment No.3 to the vote.

     

    Conservative Group Amendment No.3

     

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

    1

    Allcock

     

    x

     

    28

    Lewry

    ?

     

    2

    Appich

     

    x

     

    29

    Littman

    Not present

    3

    Atkinson

     

    x

     

    30

    Lloyd

     

    x

     

    4

    Bagaeen

    Not present

    31

    Mac Cafferty

     

    x

     

    5

    Barnett

    ?

    x

     

    32

    McNair

    ?

     

     

    6

    Bell

    ?

    x

     

    33

    Meadows

    ?

     

     

    7

    Brennan

    Not present

     

    Mears

    ?

     

     

    8

    Brown

    ?

     

    35

    Miller

    Not present

    9

    Childs

     

    x

     

    36

    Moonan

    x

     

    10

    Clare

     

    x

     

    37

    Nemeth

    ?

     

    11

    Davis

     

    x

     

    38

    Nield

    Not present

    12

    Deane

     

    x

     

    39

    O’Quinn

    x

     

    13

    Druitt

     

    x

     

    40

    Osborne

    x

     

    14

    Ebel

     

    x

     

    41

    Peltzer Dunn

    ?

     

    15

    Evans

     

    x

     

    42

    Phillips

    Not present

    16

    Fishleigh

    Not present

    43

    Pissaridou

     

    x

     

    17

    Fowler

     

    x

     

    44

    Platts

     

    x

     

    18

    Gibson

     

    x

     

    45

    Powell

     

    x

     

    19

    Grimshaw

     

    x

     

    46

    Rainey

    Not present

    20

    Hamilton

    Not present

    47

    Robins

    x

     

    21

    Heley

    x

     

    48

    Shanks

    x

     

    22

    Henry

    Not present

    49

    Simson

    ?

     

     

     

    Hills

    x

     

    ?

    Theobald C

    ?

     

     

    24

    Hugh-Jones

    x

     

    51

    Wilkinson

     

    x

     

    25

    Janio

    ?

     

    52

    Williams

     

    x

     

    26

    John

    Not present

    53

    West

     

    x

     

    27

    Knight

    x

     

    54

    Yates

    x

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Total

    12

    31

    0

     

    83.32      The mayor confirmed that the amendment had been lost by 12 votes to 31 against with 0 abstentions.

     

    83.33      The mayor then put the Conservative Group amendment No.4 to the vote.

     

    Conservative Group Amendment No.4

     

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

    1

    Allcock

     

    x

     

    28

    Lewry

    ?

     

    2

    Appich

     

    x

     

    29

    Littman

    Not present

    3

    Atkinson

     

    x

     

    30

    Lloyd

     

    x

     

    4

    Bagaeen

    Not present

    31

    Mac Cafferty

     

    x

     

    5

    Barnett

    ?

    x

     

    32

    McNair

    ?

     

     

    6

    Bell

    ?

    x

     

    33

    Meadows

    ?

     

     

    7

    Brennan

    Not present

     

    Mears

    ?

     

     

    8

    Brown

    ?

     

    35

    Miller

    Not present

    9

    Childs

     

    x

     

    36

    Moonan

    x

     

    10

    Clare

     

    x

     

    37

    Nemeth

    ?

     

    11

    Davis

     

    x

     

    38

    Nield

    Not present

    12

    Deane

     

    x

     

    39

    O’Quinn

    x

     

    13

    Druitt

     

    x

     

    40

    Osborne

    x

     

    14

    Ebel

     

    x

     

    41

    Peltzer Dunn

    ?

     

    15

    Evans

     

    x

     

    42

    Phillips

    Not present

    16

    Fishleigh

    Not present

    43

    Pissaridou

     

    x

     

    17

    Fowler

     

    x

     

    44

    Platts

     

    x

     

    18

    Gibson

     

    x

     

    45

    Powell

     

    x

     

    19

    Grimshaw

     

    x

     

    46

    Rainey

    Not present

    20

    Hamilton

    Not present

    47

    Robins

    x

     

    21

    Heley

    x

     

    48

    Shanks

    x

     

    22

    Henry

    Not present

    49

    Simson

    ?

     

     

     

    Hills

    x

     

    ?

    Theobald C

    ?

     

     

    24

    Hugh-Jones

    x

     

    51

    Wilkinson

     

    x

     

    25

    Janio

    ?

     

    52

    Williams

     

    x

     

    26

    John

    Not present

    53

    West

     

    x

     

    27

    Knight

    x

     

    54

    Yates

    x

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Total

    12

    31

    0

     

    83.34      The mayor confirmed that the amendment had been lost by 12 votes to 31 against with 0 abstentions.

     

    83.35      The mayor then put the Conservative Group amendment No.5 to the vote.

     

    Conservative Group Amendment No.5

     

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

    1

    Allcock

     

    x

     

    28

    Lewry

    ?

     

    2

    Appich

     

    x

     

    29

    Littman

    Not present

    3

    Atkinson

     

    x

     

    30

    Lloyd

     

    x

     

    4

    Bagaeen

    Not present

    31

    Mac Cafferty

     

    x

     

    5

    Barnett

    ?

    x

     

    32

    McNair

    ?

     

     

    6

    Bell

    ?

    x

     

    33

    Meadows

    ?

     

     

    7

    Brennan

    Not present

     

    Mears

    ?

     

     

    8

    Brown

    ?

     

    35

    Miller

    Not present

    9

    Childs

     

    x

     

    36

    Moonan

    x

     

    10

    Clare

     

    x

     

    37

    Nemeth

    ?

     

    11

    Davis

     

    x

     

    38

    Nield

    Not present

    12

    Deane

     

    x

     

    39

    O’Quinn

    x

     

    13

    Druitt

     

    x

     

    40

    Osborne

    x

     

    14

    Ebel

     

    x

     

    41

    Peltzer Dunn

    ?

     

    15

    Evans

     

    x

     

    42

    Phillips

    Not present

    16

    Fishleigh

    Not present

    43

    Pissaridou

     

    x

     

    17

    Fowler

     

    x

     

    44

    Platts

     

    x

     

    18

    Gibson

     

    x

     

    45

    Powell

     

    x

     

    19

    Grimshaw

     

    x

     

    46

    Rainey

    Not present

    20

    Hamilton

    Not present

    47

    Robins

    x

     

    21

    Heley

    x

     

    48

    Shanks

    x

     

    22

    Henry

    Not present

    49

    Simson

    ?

     

     

     

    Hills

    x

     

    ?

    Theobald C

    ?

     

     

    24

    Hugh-Jones

    x

     

    51

    Wilkinson

     

    x

     

    25

    Janio

     

    x

     

    52

    Williams

     

    x

     

    26

    John

    Not present

    53

    West

     

    x

     

    27

    Knight

    x

     

    54

    Yates

    x

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Total

    11

    32

    0

     

    83.36      The mayor confirmed that the amendment had been lost by 11 votes to 32 with 0 abstentions.

     

    83.37      The mayor then put the Conservative Group amendment No.6 to the vote.

     

    Conservative Group Amendment No.6

     

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

     

     

    For

    Against

    Abstain

    1

    Allcock

     

    x

     

    28

    Lewry

    ?

     

    2

    Appich

     

    x

     

    29

    Littman

    Not present

    3

    Atkinson

     

    x

     

    30

    Lloyd

     

    x

     

    4

    Bagaeen

    Not present

    31

    Mac Cafferty

     

    x

     

    5

    Barnett

    ?

    x

     

    32

    McNair

    ?

     

     

    6

    Bell

    ?

    x

     

    33

    Meadows

    ?

     

     

    7

    Brennan

    Not present

     

    Mears

    ?

     

     

    8

    Brown

    ?

     

    35

    Miller

    Not present

    9

    Childs

     

    x

     

    36

    Moonan

    x

     

    10

    Clare