Agenda item - Chair's Communication

skip navigation and tools

Agenda item

Chair's Communication

Minutes:

25.1    The Chair gave the following communication:

 

Good evening and welcome to this Call-in meeting of the Place Overview & Scrutiny Committee. I’d like to thank everyone for attending this meeting at such short notice. This was unfortunately the only possible slot for a meeting that fitted with constitutional requirements and the availability of key people and the chamber. I’d like to inform those present that this meeting is being webcast live and will be capable of repeated viewing.  

 

I’d like to start off by briefly explaining the purpose of a call-in meeting. If anyone has any questions, I’m sure that Giles will be happy to respond. 

 

Call-in is an essential and legally required part of the Leader and Cabinet model, providing a mechanism for non-executive members to challenge executive decisions before they are implemented. 

It is not intended to be used simply because members disagree with a decision. To be accepted, a call-in request must set out valid grounds for challenge in accordance with the Council’s procedure rules and be supported by at least six members from at least two political groups. In this case, the grounds are that there was an absence of sufficient evidence on which to base a decision.? 

 

In a moment, I am going to ask Cllr McNair to present this call-in on the Red Route. I’ll then ask Cllr Taylor to respond before moving to questions and discussion. Officers are here to support and provide any clarifications as needed. Once members are happy to do so, we’ll move to voting on the recommendations before us. The call-in committee essentially has 2 choices: it can agree that the Cabinet decision was sound, in which case it will not refer it back and the decision can be implemented. Or it can decide that there were significant problems with the way in which the Cabinet decision was made, in which case it will refer it back to Cabinet for reconsideration, noting the aspects of the decision that are of particular concern. 

  

There is a third choice technically open to the committee, that of referral to Council. This can only be done if the committee believes that the original Cabinet decision was contrary to the Council’s policy or budget framework. As there is nothing in the call-in letter suggesting that the decision was contrary to the budget or policy framework, I don’t think this is an option for us today. I do want to be clear that the only way that the committee can refer to Council is on the grounds that the decision is contrary to the budget or policy framework; otherwise, if members wish to refer the decision back it must be to the original decision maker which was Cabinet. 

 

It is very important for members to bear in mind that they are not being asked to debate the merits of the original executive decision. Rather, they are being asked to consider whether the Cabinet decision was properly made, given the concerns about process outlined in the call-in request. I do ask that we limit questions to the process of decision-making. I will stop questioners if they are veering too far from the brief of the committee. 

   

Finally, when the committee comes to decide whether or not to refer the Red Route decision back to Cabinet, only voting members, that is Councillors, will vote. Non-voting members are otherwise welcome to play a full part in questioning and debating the issue. 

 

 

 


Brighton & Hove City Council | Hove Town Hall | Hove | BN3 3BQ | Tel: (01273) 290000 | Mail: info@brighton-hove.gov.uk | how to find us | comments & complaints