Agenda item - BH2022/01478 - 20 Woodlands, Hove - Householder Planning Consent

1.       The Planning Manager introduced the application to the Committee.

          Answer to Committee Member Questions

2.       Councillor Theobald sought clarification regarding any trees which would be removed in consequence of the development. Councillor Theobald expressed disappointment that an unusual tree in front of the site had already been removed. Councillor Theobald also enquired regarding the remodelling of the building, including the provision of windows to the side elevations. It was confirmed that a number of elements of this scheme had already received approval under a previous permission for a similar proposal.

3.       Councillor Shanks also enquired regarding the impact on trees at the site, noting the concerns set out in the letter of objection received from Ward Councillor Brown. It was explained that as no works were proposed to the front of the building and any trees along the frontage would not be affected. The scheme had been amended throughout the course of the application, including reducing the depth setting it in from the southeast boundary and including a 1.8m privacy screen.

4.       In answer to questions by Councillor Robins it was confirmed that the existing beech tree in front of the property did not form part of the site and would not be affected by it.

          Debate

5.       Councillor Theobald considered that the proposed form of development would be large and overly dominant and with windows to the side elevation was not in keeping with the local street scene, was out of proportion with its neighbours and was not acceptable in her view. She was also concerned regarding loss of trees on site. The Planning Manager explained that there were no trees subject to Tree Preservation Orders on the site, and that the storage of construction materials on the highway, including around trees, could be controlled through existing regulations.

          Vote

6.       A vote was taken and on a vote of 6 to 2 with 2 abstentions the Committee agreed to grant planning permission.

7.       RESOLVED – That the Committee has taken into consideration and agrees with the reasons for the recommendation subject to Conditions and Informatives set out in the report.